The
Charity Commission United Kingdom which regulates charity organisations
in the country, has declared Pastor Chris Oyakhilome's church
insolvent.
Pastor Chris
The United Kingdom branch of Christ Embassy, owned by popular
Nigerian televangelist, Chris Oyakhilome, is broke and has been declared
insolvent by the Charity Commission, the agency that regulates charity
organisations in the country.
The ministry also admitted in its belated 2015 financial Statement
(the church’s last annual return, which it published in 2017) that its
subsidiary, Christ Embassy Limited, valued with a net asset of more than
N1 billion (£2 million) entered into liquidation from November 1, 2016.
On its website, the Charity Commission flagged Christ Embassy as
“charity insolvent”. According to the commission, a charity is
considered as being insolvent when it is “unable to pay its debts.”
“In practice there are two separate tests for insolvency and
failure of either might be an indication of insolvency: The charity
cannot pay its debts as they fall due for payment; The value of its
liabilities exceeds its assets.
“Charities will be flagged as insolvent on our register when we
are made aware of an insolvency situation and we are provided with
verification from a qualified, independent insolvency practitioner.” the commission explained.
The church’s present financial problem is another episode in a series of crisis that has plagued the church since 2013.
In 2014, Mr. Oyakhilome lost a fierce power tussle over the church
in the UK with his ex-wife, Anita. Though she, now known as Anita
Ebhodaghe Schafer, was the head of the UK branch of the church, Mr.
Oyakilome presided over the charity’s board of trustee since inception
until he was forced to resign in 2014.
After he was kicked out of the church’s board of trustee, the
former flamboyant couple went their separate ways in a bitter divorce
five months later.
In 2013, the UK government set up an inquiry into possible
financial misplacement of the church’s fund between 2008 and 2012.
Government-appointed auditors later raised eyebrows over suspicious
payments worth N2.14 billion (£4.28 million) made to companies and
organisation closely related to the church in 2013.
Dwindling income, increasing expenditure
Though the Charity Commission did not immediately respond to
PREMIUM TIMES’ request for further details about the circumstances
leading to the church being declared insolvent, a peep into its
financial history shows that the church started bleeding about 16 months
before Mr Oyakhilome was removed as a trustee of the church.
In 2012 Christ Embassy, UK was in perhaps its best position
financially. Its membership was growing in multiples and donations
including tithes and offerings were ballooning. New chapters were opened
all across the UK. In England, new chapters were opened in Bridgend,
Peterborough, Swindon, Stockton and a third chapter in Manchester.
Similarly, in Scotland, new chapters were opened in Aberdeen, Edinburgh,
Dundee and Glasgow.
Though in the year, its expenditure was N4.49 billion (£8.88
million), the church had an income of N8.43 billion (£16.72 million),
which left it with a surplus of N3.96 billion (£7.84 million) excluding a
gift of over N1 billion (£2 million) in net asset donated to it by its
subsidiary, Christ Embassy Limited.
“The ministry is therefore in a comfortable position to meet all financial commitments and projections for the coming year,” the church boasted.
The first whiff of problem appeared after the church turned in its
financial statement in 2013. The church’s income was N7.1 billion (£14.1
million) which was a drop of N1.3 billion (£2.6 million) from the
income of the previous year.
However, its expenditure rose drastically to N8 billion (£15.9
million), which is an increase of N3.5 billion (£7 million). Thus, from a
surplus of N3.96 billion (£7.89million) the previous year, the church
slumped into a deficit of N961.6 million (£1.9 million).
Despite the drastic slump in income, the church was still
optimistic about its future: “The Ministry remains in a comfortable
position to meet all its financial commitments and projections for the
coming year,” it stated.
In 2014, the church’s income continued on its downward trajectory
while its expenditure stayed high. Its income dropped to N6.7 billion
(£13.2 million). But due to cuts in its expenditure, the church managed
to make a surplus of N506 million (£1 million).
In 2015, Christ Embassy took its biggest hit. Income for the year
was N2.3 billion (£4.7 million) from the N6.7 billion (£13.2 million)
the previous year, while expenditure rose to over N5 billion
(approximately £10 million). Thus, its deficit for the year amounted to
just over N1.7 billion (£3.2 million).
The fees paid to Rod Weston of the international audit and
accounting firm, Mazars LLP, who was appointed by the Charity Commission
to take over the management of the church, may cause the increase in
the church’s expenditure in 2014 and 2015.
The ministry’s annual return for both years indicated that a total
of N7.6 billion (£15.1million) was paid to the interim manager. The
church still has an outstanding fee of N1.1 billion (£2215,914) to pay
the interim manager in 2015.
When reached for comments, an official of the church, who refused
to identify himself, was furious that this newspaper wanted to do a
story about the church.
“Why do you need the information? What story? Who gave you the story to work on? Why are you calling?," he asked.
When told that ethically journalists are required to talk to the
subjects of their stories to write balanced reports, he said there was
no need to ask the church any question.
“If you are a journalist and you got your story from anywhere
why do you need to balance it, you go ahead. There is no need to
clarify,” he said.
Incestuous transactions
Worried by the ministry’s sudden increase in expenditure, on 11
August 2014, the Charity Commission side-lined the church’s board of
trustees and appointed an interim manager, Rod Weston of the
international audit and accounting firm, Mazars, to take over the
management of the church.
Before setting aside the church’s board of trustees, the commission
had discovered controversial payments worth N1.8 billion (£3.6 million)
to foreign entities between 2008 and 2012.
The Charity Commission explained at the time that the statutory
inquiry would investigate Christ Embassy over “a number of serious
concerns relating to the use of charitable funds, in particular large
connected party payments and the potential misapplication of grant
funding”.
The commission said the church might have been imprudent in managing its finances.
Subsequently, the UK tax authority, HM Revenue and Customs, held
back N1.36 billion (£2.7 million) due to the church in donation between
2008 and 2012 until the conclusion is resolved.
But details of the 2013 financial statement, which was approved on
January 22, 2016 show that the church’s suspicious spending did not stop
in 2012.
Jacob Cavenagh and Skeet, the independent auditors, discovered that
part of the church’s £15.9 million expenditure in 2013 was made to
companies and organisations with close relation to the church.
The auditors particularly raised eyebrows over the N1.35 billion
(£2,679,980) paid to Loveworld Limited for transmission of the church’s
broadcast. Interestingly, a trustee of the church, Obioma Chiemeka, is
the director and sole shareholder of Loveworld Limited. Mr Chiemeke, a
pastor, however resigned as a trustee on October 15, 2015.
Also, purchases worth N22.7 million (£44,925) were made from
Ventaja Ltd for decorating and the construction of a stage. The auditors
discovered that a pastor of the church, Tony Obi, was the sole
shareholder of the Ventaja and his wife Georgine Obi, an employee of
Christ Embassy, was a director of the company. Mr Obi, however, resigned
as a trustee of the church on November 6, 2015.
The auditors said they were also not convinced about the reason for
a grant of N506.9 million (£1,000,973) given to Healing School, Canada.
A trustee of the UK branch of the Church. Ray Okocha, a reverend, is
also a trustee of Healing School Canada.
Healing School is the branch of the church in charge of faith
healing and miracles sessions. It regularly hosts events in
Johannesburg, South Africa; and Toronto, Canada.
The auditors said they could not obtain “complete and accurate”
information on the transactions because the church could not provide
explanations and information they requested during the audit.
“The audit evidence available to us are limited because we were
unable to obtain sufficient evidence to enable us to conclude whether
material amount of expenditure made by the charity were charitable
expenditure,” the auditors stated.
“The audit evidence available to us are also limited because we
were unable to obtain complete and accurate information on related
parties. As a result of this we were unable to determine whether further
disclosure of related parties and related party transaction should be
made in financial statement.
“The audit evidence were also limited because a number of
explanations and information requested during our audit could not be
provided,” it said.
Source: PREMIUM Times
When News Breaks Out, We Break In. (The 2014 Bloggies Finalist)
No comments:
Post a Comment